Epic Fail……….

We have been working on our refinance for about 6 months now.  It has been a very frustrating time for both my wife and I.  There hasn’t been a simple problem, only tough ones, ranging from not having the title to our house, to not enough comparable sales for our appraisal to be approved.  The former being something that we could handle and the latter being completely out of our control.  Along the way we have felt frustration, hope, more frustration, excitement and last but not least, failure.

Last Friday I called our mortgage officer.  Feb 27th was supposed to be our last day of the lock-in period.  I knew he was going to extend it by a week because we were waiting on one more sale to go through, and see if the underwriters would approve that sale as a comparable.  So last monday that sale closed, the one we were waiting on for the underwriters to approve our appraisal, which was the last step before closing.  The underwriters decided to decline that sale as a comparable.  Pretty much stopping our refinance from happening.

The refi is on the back-burner for now, so that leaves us with some options on other stuff.  We had money saved up about 9k to pay down our mortgage to get a VA loan, so now we have to decide what we want to do with that money.  Here are some options.

  • Still pay down the mortgage, about $8400 to get it down to the original appraisal’s 20% equity and get rid of PMI, saving $106/month plus the interest savings over the life of the loan.  This would also let us get a later refi without putting any more $ down.
  • Pay off the camper, about $7500, saving $236/month.
  • Pay off Student loan, about $3900, saving $70/month.
  • Keep the money in savings.
  • Buy a brand new motocross bike?

I think the best route to go here is to put it towards the mortgage.  Over the long run I think it’s the best option to go with.  We would still have the other loans, but the goal of paying those off by years end is still the goal considering we had earmarked that money for the mortgage pay down.  Our mortgage officer told us that another option for us is to wait until the more active selling season (summertime) is over, talk to some real estate agents and see how sales were with houses that are comparable to ours and then reapply for the refinance.  I think that by going with the 1st option, we would already have the mortgage paid down far enough to not put any extra down if we were able to refi in the fall.  The camper and student loan would still be there for a while but will still be paid off by years end.

As frustrating as this whole refinance has been, I am trying to take some good from it.

  • We have the title in our name now.
  • Our savings rate has increased by cutting back on other stuff.
  • We now have a plan to attack our debt.

Which option do you think is best and why?  Can you think of other options that I might have?


9 responses to “Epic Fail……….

  • BrokeElizabeth

    Sorry the refi didn’t go through :(. I would pay down the mortgage, and then put any extra money towards the student loan to get it out of the way…. but it’s a bit hard to say without knowing the interest rates of all of the loans.

    • debtntaxes

      We have another option which is to talk to our current mortgage holder about a refinance, which I did today, and from the way it sounds, he said the comparible sales shouldn’t be a problem. The interest rate is a little bit higher by a .25 point, but it will still be massive savings if it goes through. I am trying to be optimistic from the way he sounded.

  • Alice at Dont Debt

    I would go with paying off the camper loan. That is likely to have the highest interest rate and would be the best way to increase cash flow. If cash flow isn’t a problem, then simply take that $236 per month, or some portion of it and apply it to the principle on the mortgage.

    • debtntaxes

      The way we are looking at it is longer term savings. The refinance would give us the best and most long-term savings. The camper is at a higher % rate than the refinance and it would be nice to have the camper payment gone, but with the savings from the mortgage (roughly $317/month) we could just add that amount to the camper payment.

  • debtntaxes

    @not a sack holder- That’s what we are thinking also

  • John | Married (with Debt)

    Looks like a tough situation. A coworker just made the plunge, but he had his bank calling him every other week to talk him into it. Was a good deal for him.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: